The Church of Christ on the Little Blue River was first started some time in the 1830s, Meetings were first held out doors in a grove of trees near where the present church building is located. At a meeting of the church members at the home of Clement Murphey on 28 Nov 1840, for the purpose of more fully organizing the church in accordance of law, by appointing or electing trustees for the church. A motion was made, and unanimously agreed that the following named individuals would be chosen trustees until their successors were chosen according to law; Asahel Woodward, Benjamin Harvey, Clement Murphey, Nathan Cannaday and William Millikan Sr. They proceeded immediately to build or erect a church house or house for worship and a burial ground on one acre of ground donated by Clement Murphey.

                                      

    The following names are the original 66 members who formed the Church of Christ. Elizabeth Baxter, Thomas Baxter, Elizabeth Bouselog, Martha Bowers, Martha Brandon, Elizabeth Bundy, Mary Bundy, James Burcham, Mary Burcham, Nathan Cannaday, Samuel Cannaday, William Cannaday, LLD Cary, Mary Cary, Josiah Clawson, Phebe Clawson, James Cole, Sarah J. Cole, Joseph Dinor, Susannah Finney, Ruth Fleek, Eliza Mariah Fraizer, Jane Fraizer, May Fraizer, William Fraizer, Sarah Frazer, Mary Harden, Tary Harden, Alby Harvey, Benjamin Harvey, Elizabeth Harvey, Jacob Harvey, Richard Haynes, Susan Haynes, William Haynes, Joseph Koons, Lucinda Koons, Jemima Leason, Rachael Leason, Susannah Mansfield, William Mansfield, Elijah Martindale, Elizabeth Martindale, Ruth Massey, William Massey, James Mclellen, Jane McLellen, William Millikan, Clement Murphey, Huldah Murphey, Malinda Ray, Mariah Ray, Martha Ray, Thomas Ray, Emily Ridgeway, Noah Ridgeway, Margaret Shively, Abigale Smith, Ann Smith, Cornelius Smith, Lucinda Smith, Mary Smith, George Tiney, Asahel Woodward and Catharine Woodward.
The complete records (1840 - 1987) for the Church of Christ on the Little Blue River are available at the Henry County Historical Society Museum in New Castle, IN